Table 2

Compliance with hand hygiene related to the use of the liquid (phase I) or the gel (phase II) handrub formulation


Phase Ia
Phase IIa
P value

Overall compliance
32.1 (194/604)
41.2 (228/553)
0.035
Health care worker category



     Nurses
33.6 (167/497)
45.7 (190/416)
0.011
     Physicians
25.8 (16/62)
28.6 (16/56)
0.76
     Nursing assistants
32.0 (8/25)
30.8 (20/65)
0.74
     Other
15.0 (3/20)
12.5 (2/16)
0.84
Time of day



     Morning
35.0 (106/303)
46.7 (160/343)
0.039
     Afternoon
29.2 (88/301)
32.4 (68/210)
0.75
Workload (number of opportunities per hour)



     <10
40.5 (36/89)
33.3 (38/114)
0.29
     10–15
39.0 (62/159)
38.0 (89/234)
0.86
     ≥16
27.0 (96/356)
49.3 (101/205)
< 0.001
Patient isolated



     Yes
32.0 (65/203)
35.1 (53/151)
0.9
     No
32.2 (129/401)
43.5 (175/402)
0.017
Availability of handrub



     Yes
46.9 (23/49)
55.9 (19/34)
0.53
     No
30.8 (171/555)
40.3 (209/519)
0.035
Availability of alcohol-based solution in the room



     Yes
32.3 (193/598)
41.0 (224/547)
0.05
     No
16.7 (1/6)
66.7 (4/6)
0.068
Type of opportunity



     Respiratory care
40 (16/40)
31.9 (15/47)
0.56
     Intravenous or arterial care
24.2 (15/62)
36.7 (22/60)
0.17
     Direct patient contact
31.7 (151/477)
39.0 (146/374)
0.13
     Digestive tract care
0 (0/6)
25 (3/12)
NA
     Wound care
55.6 (5/9)
74.3 (26/35)
0.24
     Clean device
77.8 (7/9)
77.8 (14/18)
0.87
     Urinary care
0 (0/1)
28.6 (2/7)
NA

aData not in parentheses are presented as percentages. NA, not applicable.

Traore et al. Critical Care 2007 11:R52   doi:10.1186/cc5906