Early decompressive craniectomy and duraplasty for refractory intracranial hypertension in children: results of a pilot study

cc2361 CCJ Research Early decompressive craniectomy and duraplasty for refractory intracranial hypertension in children: results of a pilot study Ruf Bettina bettina.ruf@paediat.med.uni-giessen.de Heckmann Matthias Schroth Ilona Hügens-Penzel Monika Reiss Irwin Borkhardt Arndt Gortner Ludwig Jödicke Andreas

Department of Pediatrics, University Medical Centre, Justus-Liebig-University, Giessen, Germany

Department of Neurosurgery, University Medical Centre, Justus-Liebig-University, Giessen, Germany

Department of Neuroradiology, University Medical Centre, Justus-Liebig-University, Giessen, Germany

Professor, Department of Pediatrics, University Medical Centre, Justus-Liebig-University, Giessen, Germany

Critical Care 1364-8535 2003 7 6 R133 R138 http://ccforum.com/content/7/6/R133 See related Commentary: http://ccforum.com/content/7/6/409 10.1186/cc2361 14624687 19 6 2003 10 7 2003 18 7 2003 22 7 2003 10 9 2003 2003 Ruf et al., licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article: verbatim copying and redistribution of this article are permitted in all media for any purpose, provided this notice is preserved along with the article's original URL. craniectomy intensive care pediatric severe head injury

Abstract

Introduction

Severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) in childhood is associated with a high mortality and morbidity. Decompressive craniectomy has regained therapeutic interest during past years; however, treatment guidelines consider it a last resort treatment strategy for use only after failure of conservative therapy.

Patients

We report on the clinical course of six children treated with decompressive craniectomy after TBI at a pediatric intensive care unit. The standard protocol of intensive care treatment included continuous intracranial pressure (ICP) monitoring, sedation and muscle relaxation, normothermia, mild hyperventilation and catecholamines to maintain an adequate cerebral perfusion pressure. Decompressive craniectomy including dura opening was initiated in cases of a sustained increase in ICP > 20 mmHg for > 30 min despite maximally intensified conservative therapy (optimized sedation and ventilation, barbiturates or mannitol).

Results

In all cases, the ICP normalized immediately after craniectomy. At discharge, three children were without disability, two children had a mild arm-focused hemiparesis (one with a verbal impairment), and one child had a spastic hemiparesis and verbal impairment. This spastic hemiparesis improved within 6 months follow-up (no motor deficit, increased muscle tone), and all others remained unchanged.

Conclusion

These observational pilot data indicate feasibility and efficacy of decompressive craniectomy in malignant ICP rise secondary to TBI. Further controlled trials are necessary to evaluate the indication and standardization of early decompressive craniectomy as a 'second tier' standard therapy in pediatric severe head injury.

Introduction

Severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) (Glasgow Coma Scale < 8) occurs in 60% of polytraumatized children after car accidents or child abuse, and it is associated with a high mortality and morbidity 12. The primary therapeutic aim is to maintain an adequate cerebral blood flow (estimated from cerebral perfusion pressure) and brain oxygenation. Intensive care management of severe head injury in cases of refractory intracranial pressure (ICP) is not based on controlled, randomized studies. Studies in adults report more side effects than positive benefits 3.

Decompressive craniectomy has regained some therapeutic interest during the past decade. However, treatment guidelines for traumatic brain injury from German, European (European Brain Injury Consortium 4) North-American (Brain Trauma Foundation 5) and international (pediatric neurosurgery) 6 medical societies consider decompressive craniectomy only as last resort treatment strategy after failure of conservative therapy. In the pediatric population, a mere handful of case reports, cohort studies and pilot studies discuss the indication for decompressive craniectomy 78. We report on the clinical course of six pediatric patients enrolled in a pilot study secondary to decompressive craniectomy after TBI.

Patients

All patients were immediately treated by the medical emergency team at the accident site and transferred to the Pediatric Intensive Care Unit (see Table 1 for details on diagnosis, treatment and follow-up). Early parameters of treatment at admission were transcutaneous oxygen saturation > 92% and an estimated cerebral perfusion pressure of at least 50 mmHg.

Table 1

Basic clinical data and course in study infants

Patient

Age (years)

Sex

Type of trauma

Glasgow Coma Scale on admission

Peak ICP (mmHg)

Initial cranial CT

Extent of craniectomy

Timepoint of craniectomy (days post-trauma)

Extubation (days post-trauma)

Female

Fall (3 m)

Bilateral skull fracture, infratentorial tSAH, DBS

Bilateral

1 and 2

Female

Fall (5 m)

Right-sided frontal brain contusion and tSAH, secondary DBS

Bilateral

3 and 5

Female

Child abuse

Right-sided acute subdural hematoma, extensive DBS

Right

Male

Car accident

Unilateral skull fracture; brain contusion in frontal lobe, basal ganglia and corpus callosum (DAI)

Bilateral

Male

Car accident

Left-sided calvarial and skull base fracture, tSAH, DBS

Left

Female

Kick by a horse

Left-sided temporal brain contusions, traumatic ventricular bleeding, infratentorial tSAH

Suboccipital

CT, computed tomography; DAI, diffuse axonal injury; DBS, diffuse brain swelling; ICP, intracranial pressure; tSAH, traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage.

Standard protocol of treatment

After emergent clinical evaluation with stabilization of ventilation and hemodynamics, a computed tomography (CT) scan was initiated. Significant traumatic masses were treated surgically on an emergency basis. In all other cases, an external ventriculostomy was performed and/or an ICP monitor was inserted. Insertion of an external ventriculostomy was performed in cases with accessible ventricles on admission for cerebrospinal fluid drainage as required by ICP monitoring. The ICP was monitored continuously by an intraparenchymal probe (MicroSensor; Codman, Johnson & Johnson, Raynham, MA, USA) in all cases. The treatment protocol generally applied was sedation and continuous muscle relaxation, 15–30° elevation of the upper part of the body, normothermia (36–37°C), and mild hyperventilation (pCO₂= 30–35 mmHg). To maintain a sufficient cerebral perfusion pressure (50–60 mmHg; see 9), all patients received catecholamines (epinephrine and norepinephrine) as needed.

Intensified treatment protocol

Standard therapy was intensified in cases of an ICP increase > 20 mmHg for at least 30 min. Body position, body temperature, blood pressure, fluid management and ventilation as well as analgosedation were evaluated and optimized in order to lower the ICP. In each case of an unexpected and sustained elevation of ICP, a current CT scan was evaluated to rule out new space occupying intracranial lesions 10. Continuing and sustained deviation of the ICP > 20 mmHg for longer than 30 min was treated by single doses of barbiturate (2–5 mg/kg) and by infusion of mannitol (0.5 g/kg in 15 min). No treatment response within 30 min or even a further increase of ICP lead to immediate surgical treatment (decompressive craniectomy).

Surgical procedure

A unilateral or bilateral fronto-temporo-parietal craniectomy was performed depending on the extent and location of the brain swelling. The removed bone flap was stored by kryopreservation until secondary cranioplasty. The dura was opened and enlarged by an autologous galeal flap or by a Goretex patch. In patient 1, dura enlargement was restricted to one side despite bilateral decompression. In patient 6 (cerebellar contusion), a suboccipital craniectomy and duraplasty was performed because of a cerebellar swelling and altered somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP), in addition to a severe head trauma after blunt injury to the craniocervical junction.

Results

Immediate postoperative course

In five out of six patients, the ICP normalized (< 12 mmHg) immediately after craniectomy and no secondary elevation in ICP was noticed. The continuous sedation and muscle relaxation could be tapered and stopped on day 5 or day 6 after surgical decompression.

Special clinical courses

Patient 2 showed a secondary brain swelling with an increase of ICP level intractable to intensified medical treatment on day 4 after unilateral decompression. A craniectomy of the contralateral side was therefore performed, with subsequent normalization of the ICP. Figure 1 presents the CT scan before and Figure 2 after bilateral craniectomy of patient 2.

Figure 1

CT scan of patient 2 before craniectomy

CT scan of patient 2 before craniectomy.

Figure 2

CT scan of patient 2 after bilateral craniectomy

CT scan of patient 2 after bilateral craniectomy.

Complications

There was neither infection nor disturbance of wound healing, nor mortality.

One patient (patient 3) developed a late aseptic necrosis of the replaced bone flap. In this case, a post-traumatic hydrocephalus led to subgaleal cerebrospinal fluid collection with surgical revision and transient insertion of a ventriculo-peritoneal shunt. This might have caused insufficient fixation of the bone flap and a lack of revascularization with subsequent partial necrosis. The shunt was removed 3 months after trauma and the bony defect was covered by an autologous calvarial split graft.

Neurological outcome

The neurological outcomes at discharge and at 6 months follow-up are presented in Table 2. Furthermore, SEP of the median nerve before and after decompressive craniectomy are described in Table 2.

Table 2

Neurological outcome of patients with decompressive craniectomy at discharge and after 6 months compared with somatosensory evoked potentials of the median nerve (M-SEP) before and after craniectomy

Patient

Neurological status (on demission)

Neurological status (6 months post-trauma)

M-SEP (prior to craniectomy)

M-SEP (first week after craniectomy)

Normal

Not tested

Moderate impairment (right)

Normal

Severe impairment (right)

Normal

Left-sided hemiparesis, VP shunt (PTH)

Distinct improvement of hemiparesis predominantly of the left arm, VP shunt removed

Not tested

Severe impairment (right)

Central impairment of coordination with tremor and ataxia; predominantly right-sided spasticity; speech retardation

Residual spasticity but not impaired in motor skills; visits a normal school

Moderate impairment (right), severe impairment (left)

Mild impairment (left)

Normal

Not tested

Normal

Hemiparesis predominatly of the right arm; left-sided abducent nerve paresis; impairment of swallowing and speech

Rehabilitation

Mild impairment (right), moderate impairment (left)

Severe impairment (left)

PTH, post-traumatic hydrocephalus; VP shunt, ventriculo–peritoneal shunt.

Patient 1 suffered from a severe transitional syndrome after discontinuation of sedation. The neurological status was normal after recovery, in spite of pathological SEP of the median nerve. At discharge from the intensive care unit, patient 2 showed a hemiparesis, predominantly of the left arm, which resolved to normal strength in the following weeks.

None of the patients with severe head injury suffered from post-traumatic seizures or received anticonvulsive medication. Based on findings for SEP of the median nerve, a favorable and stable long-term outcome could be predicted for all of our patients suffering from TBI, confirming previously published data 11. The SEP 1 week after trauma correlated with the neurological outcome 6 months after trauma, except for patient 1. Mild disturbances of SEP were seen in patient 1, but revealed no deterioration during follow-up.

Discussion

After exclusion or surgical removal of traumatic hematomas and other space occupying lesions, prevention of secondary brain injury is the mainstay of intensive care treatment in pediatric severe head injury. Diffuse brain swelling and multiple cerebral contusions are the most common cause of morbidity and death after severe head injury in pediatric patients 12.

Standardized treatment protocols have been suggested for the management of severe head injury in children 13, including drainage of cerebrospinal fluid, mild hyperventilation (pCO₂lower threshold of 30 mmHg) and mannitol bolus (unless serum osmolality exceeds 320 mosmol/l) as generally accepted baseline therapies for the pediatric population 6. In cases of sustained elevated ICP (> 20 mmHg) and reduced critically cerebral perfusion pressure (< 50 mmHg), despite optimal medical therapy including controlled hyperventilation, further management using 'second tier' therapy is a matter of controversy 6 and has to follow the different stages of postinjury cerebral insults.

Brain swelling and intracranial hypertension in the early post-traumatic period has been proposed to induced by cerebral hyperemia (i.e. increased cerebral blood flow [CBF]), especially in children 1415. However, the impact of hyperemia on outcome has been rated controversially. Beneficial 1617 as well as detrimental effects have been discussed 18.

'Second tier' intensified conservative treatment will have to rely on specific prognostic monitoring parameters. Therefore, CBF-dependent therapy has been studied 19. But, as cerebral blood flow is age dependent in the unaffected child (normal range from 40 to > 100 ml/100 g/min 20, absolute cerebral hyperemia may only be defined within narrow age ranges 21. CBF thresholds cannot be taken from adult studies for the initiation of therapeutic interventions in the pediatric population.

Monitoring of cerebral metabolic parameters has been reported for treatment in adult patients. In children, an early decrease in the cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen and the arterio-venous difference for oxygen has been reported to occur 1–3 days after trauma 14. Recently, Cruz and colleagues 15 predicted clinical outcome based on monitoring of the ICP and the cerebral extraction rate for oxygen (CEO₂) in children. In their observational study of 45 children, an increased ICP and a decreased CEO₂indicated cerebral hyperemia during the first 5 days after head injury. An unfavorable outcome occurred in children with higher ICP and lower CEO₂(< 17%). Monitoring of the CEO₂(or oxygen saturation at the jugular vein bulb for hemoglobin > 12 g/l) might therefore be used to direct ventilation and medical therapy in children in the future. However, two out of 45 patients died prior to intended decompressive surgery while being monitored for CEO₂, which points towards the need for shortened monitoring intervals and early surgical decompression.

Prolonged barbiturate therapy inherits a high risk of unwanted therapeutic effects, and revealed small benefits in the outcome in children 22. In a proven state of refractory absolute hyperemia, selective reduction of the CBF by cerebral vasomodulation (dihydroergotamine, metoprolol and clonidin 22, or a monotherapy dihydroergotamine respectively 23) might be considered, but these treatment options are still not for routine application and require very intensive multimodal monitoring.

Brain edema associated with cerebral ischemia requires optimized cerebral perfusion and fluid management. Experimental medical treatment is proposed to lower the ICP and to reestablish sufficient CBF after failure of mannitol and vasopressors to support sufficient CBF. Hypertonic saline (7.2%) as a bolus or an infusion decreased the ICP in adults and children, and may therefore be indicated preferably in hypovolemia 242526.

As a surgical 'second tier' option, controlled lumbar drainage of cerebrospinal fluid has been proposed. This regimen necessitates an external ventriculostomy and discernible basal cisterns on CT with careful control of both external drainage systems. In a study cohort of 16 pediatric head injury patients, Levy and colleagues 27 reported good control of refractory intracranial hypertension without drainage-related mortality.

Surgical decompression using craniectomy is largely seen as a last resort therapeutic option. This may be due to disappointment from previous anecdotic results based on late intervention. Encouraging results have been reported from studies in adolescent and adult patients indicating an early time point of decompression as extremely important to achieve a favorable outcome 3828.

In addition to the 'optimal' time point for decompression, the extent of brain decompression seems to be important 3. Restoration of cerebral perfusion by surgical enlargement of the intracranial space is the primary goal of decompression 3. This may necessitate a large craniotomy with duraplasty. Prospective controlled, randomized studies on the effect of surgical decompression in TBI in childhood are missing. A pilot study by Taylor and colleagues 8 demonstrated an improved neurological outcome of patients who were treated with an early decompressive craniectomy in a cohort of 27 children compared with historical controls. In contrast to our patients, only a small temporal craniectomy without opening the dura was performed. The risk of transtentorial herniation can be lowered in this way, but restoration of the cerebral perfusion can hardly be achieved. However, a benefit from temporal craniectomy without duraplasty has been shown by Taylor and colleagues, which underlines the potential of a larger decompression. Studies in adults demonstrated a greater decrease of the ICP after duraplasty than in cases with craniectomy only 329.

Neither in these studies nor in our cohort was a higher rate of complications such as infections or hygroma noted due to duraplasty. Immediate normalization of the ICP after supratentorial surgical decompression was achieved in all patients from our study cohort. A good neurological outcome was achieved in all our patients suffering from TBI treated with decompressive craniectomy and duraplasty. Due to the early timepoint of decompression after failure of first-line treatment options, unwanted effects of prolonged medical therapy (e.g. barbiturate coma) or brain herniation with secondary brain stem compromise could be prevented, and all children survived.

There currently seems to be no specific treatment regimen in children compared with adults in severe head injury 21, and there is no preference for a special 'second tier' treatment strategy in pediatric head injury 6. The presented pilot trial adds an additional argument for surgical decompression at an early stage in case of treatment-refractory intracranial hypertension, and calls for a controlled trial that includes this treatment option in pediatric severe head injury patients.

Key messages

• In case of sustained increase in ICP (>20 mmHg) under intensified conservative therapy conditions and early decompressive craniectomy including duraplasty has to be considered

Conclusion

This pilot trial and the favorable results from the study by Taylor and colleagues 8 demonstrate the necessity of a multicenter, controlled, randomized study to evaluate the indication and standardization of early decompressive craniectomy as a 'second tier' standard therapy in children with severe head injury.

Competing interests

None declared.

Abbreviations

CBF = cerebral blood flow; CEO₂= cerebral extraction rate for oxygen; CT = computed tomography; ICP = intracranial pressure; SEP = somatosensory evoked potentials; TBI = traumatic brain injury.

Outcome from severe head injury in children and adolescents Berger MS Pitts LH Lovely M Edwards MS Bartkowski HM J Neurosurg 1985 62 194 199 3968558 The outcome of severe closed head injury Marshall LF Gautille T Klauber MR Eisenberg HM Jane JA Luerssen TG Marmarou A Foulkes MA J Neurosurg 1991 75 528 536 Surgical decompression for traumatic brain swelling: indication and results Guerra WK Gaab MR Dietz H Mueller JU Piek J Fritsch MJ J Neurosurg 1999 90 187 196 9950487 EBIC-guidelines for management of severe head injury in adults. European Brain Injury consortium Maas AI Dearden M Teasdale GM Braakman R Cohadon F Jannotti F Karimi A Lapierre F Murray G Ohmann J Persson L Servadei F Stochetti N Unterberg A Acta Neurochir 1997 139 286 294 Guidelines for the management of severe head injury Brain Trauma Foundation American Association of Neurological Surgeons Joint Section on Neurotrauma and Critical Care J Neurotrauma 1996 13 641 734 8941879 Head injuries: management of primary injuries and prevention of secondary damage Rekate HL Childs Nerv Syst 2000 17 632 634 10.1007/s003810100487 The place of decompressive surgery in the treatment of uncontrollable post-traumatic intracranial hypertension in children Dam Hieu P Sizun J Person H Besson G Childs Nerv Syst 1996 12 270 275 8737804 A randomized trial of very early decompressive craniectomy in children with traumatic brain injury and sustained intracranial hypertension Taylor A Butt W Rosenfeld J Shann F Ditchfield M Lewis E Klug G Wallace D Henning R Tibballs J Childs Nerv Syst 2001 17 154 162 11305769 10.1007/s003810000410 Relationship of cerebral perfusion pressure and survival in pediatric brain-injured patients Downard C Hulka F Mullins RJ Piatt J Chesnut R Quint P Mann N J Trauma 2000 49 654 658 11038082 Imaging after head trauma: why, when and which Bruce DA Childs Nerv Syst 2000 16 755 759 11151728 10.1007/s003810000336 Severe brain injury in children: long-term outcome and its prediction using somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) Carter BG Taylor A Butt W Intensive Care Med 1999 25 722 728 10470577 10.1007/s001340050936 The national traumatic coma data bank. Part 2: patients who talk and deteriorate: implications for treatment Marshall LF Toole BM Bowers SA J Neurosurg 1983 59 285 288 6864295 Prognostic factors and outcome of children with severe head injury: an 8-year experience Chiaretti A Piastra M Pulitanò S Pietrini D De Rosa G Barbaro R Di Rocco C Childs Nerv Syst 2002 18 129 136 11981619 10.1007/s00381-002-0558-3 Cerebral blood flow and metabolism in severely head-injured children: Part I – relationship to age, Glascow coma score, outcome, intracranial pressure and time after surgery Sharples PM Stuart AG Mathews DSF Synsley-Green A Eyre JA J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1995 58 145 152 7876842 Cerebral extraction of oxygen and intracranial hypertension in severe, acute, pediatric brain trauma: preliminary novel management strategies Cruz J Nakayama P Imamura JH Rosenfeld KGW De Souza HS Giorgetti GVF Neurosurgery 2002 50 774 780 11904028 Diffuse brain swelling after head injury: more often malignant in adults than in children? Lang DA Teasdale GM Macpherson P Lawrence A J Neurosurg 1994 80 675 680 8151346 Focal cerebral hyperemia after focal head injury in humans: a benign phenomenon? Sakas DE Bullock MR Patterson J Hadley D Wyper DJ Teasdale GM J Neurosurg 1995 83 277 284 7616274 Severe head injury in children: impact of risk factors on outcome Feickert HJ Drommer S Heyer R J Trauma 1999 47 33 38 10421183 Continuous regional cerebral cortical blood flow monitoring in head-injured patients Siotos PJ Orozco JA Carter LP Weinand ME Hamilton AJ Williams FC Neurosurgery 1995 36 943 950 7791986 The changes of regional cerebral blood flow with advancing age in normal children Susuki K Nagoya Med J 1990 34 159 170 Severe pediatric head injury: the role of hyperemia revisited Zwienenberg M Muizelaar JP J Neurotrauma 1999 16 937 943 10547102 Improved outcome after severe injury with a new therapy based on principles for brain volume regulation and preserved microcirculation Ecker C Asgeirsson B Grände PO Schalen W Nordström CH Crit Care Med 1998 26 1881 1886 9824083 Successful treatment of uncontrollable posttraumatic intracranial hypertension with dihydroergotamine in a child Orliaguet GA Meyer PG Renier D Blanot S Carli PA Anesth Analg 1997 85 1218 1220 9390583 A prospective, randomized, and controlled study of fluid management in children with severe head injury Simma B Burger R Falk M Sacher P Fanconi S Crit Care Med 1998 26 1265 1270 10.1097/00003246-199807000-00032 9671379 Hypertonic saline solution for control of elevated intracranial pressure in patients with exhausted response to mannitol and barbiturates Horn P Munch E Vajkoczy P Herrmann P Qintel M Schilling L Schmiedek P Schurer L Neurol Res 1999 21 758 764 10596385 Cerebral hemodynamic effects of 7.2% hypertonic saline in patients with head injury and raised intracranial pressure Munar F Ferrer AM de Nadal M Poca MA Pedraza S Sahuquillo J Garnacho A J Neurotrauma 2000 17 41 51 10674757 Controlled lumbar drainage in pediatric head injury Levy DI Rekate HL Cherny B Manwaring K Moss D Baldwin HZ J Neurosurg 1995 83 453 460 7666222 Decompressive bifrontal craniectomy in the treatment of severe refractory posttraumatic cerebral edema Polin RS Shaffrey ME Bogaev CA Tisdale N Germanson T Bocchi Jane JA Neurosurgery 1997 41 84 92 9218299 Ventrikular pressure monitoring during bilateral decompression with dural expansion Yoo DS Kim DS Cho KS Huh PW Park CK Kang JK J Neurosurg 1999 91 953 959 10584840