<?xml version='1.0'?>
<!DOCTYPE art SYSTEM 'http://www.biomedcentral.com/xml/article.dtd'>
<art>
	<ui>cc3946</ui>
	<ji>CCJ</ji>
	<fm>
		<dochead>Editorial</dochead>
		<bibl>
			<title>
				<p>Concluding thoughts on the new nature of disaster management</p>
			</title>
			<aug>
				<au id="A1" ca="yes">
					<snm>Crippen</snm>
					<fnm>David</fnm>
					<insr iid="I1"/>
				</au>
			</aug>
			<insg>
				<ins id="I1">
					<p>Associate Professor, Director, Neurovascular ICU, Department of Critical Care Medicine, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA</p>
				</ins>
			</insg>
			<source>Critical Care</source>
			<issn>1364-8535</issn>
			<pubdate>2006</pubdate>
			<volume>10</volume>
			<issue>1</issue>
			<fpage>111</fpage>
			<xrefbib>
				<pubidlist><pubid idtype="pmpid">16420651</pubid><pubid idtype="doi">10.1186/cc3946</pubid>
				</pubidlist></xrefbib>
		</bibl>
		<history>
			<pub>
				<date>
					<day>14</day>
					<month>12</month>
					<year>2005</year>
				</date>
			</pub>
		</history>
	</fm>
	<meta>
		<classifications>
			<classification type="BMC" subtype="theme_series_title" id="CC_HUR">Hurricane Katrina - disaster management</classification>
			<classification type="BMC" subtype="theme_series_editor" id="CC_HUR">David Crippen</classification>
		</classifications>
	</meta>
	<bdy>
		<sec>
			<st>
				<p>Conclusion</p>
			</st>
			<p>Environmental cataclysms will be with mankind even after we have learned to prevent man-made disasters. Prior to the Katrina hurricane, disaster planning, preparedness and responses were mostly theoretical and based on our preconceived notions of what a disaster should be <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B1">1</abbr></abbrgrp>. Mostly untested except on relative small scales. Katrina has changed that in many ways. We knew Katrina was coming. We knew with uncanny precision how it would affect us. We watched it approach, arrive and depart. We articulated what we should do and we found out vividly what we couldn't do despite our best intentions.</p>
			<p>Virtually all our previous responses to environmental disaster involved protecting citizens from adverse effects and then resuscitating survivors after the fact <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B2">2</abbr></abbrgrp>. Now, we have found that most of that paradigm has been rendered moot and radically new concepts have taken their place. As the authors for this manuscript point out, virtually all of our previous "disaster plans, including those in hospitals were woefully inadequate and failed miserably <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B3">3</abbr></abbrgrp>. Unless we learn the present and future logistical problems of environmental disasters, we cannot effectively plan for them.</p>
			<p>Part of that process is deciding whether we are more interested in constructing or blaming. Americans are notorious for blaming public officials for inadequacies, real or imagined <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B4">4</abbr></abbrgrp>. Public servants are a convenient target for blame when things go wrong. But if there is any blame, it is rarely unilateral. More to the point, assigning blame is by its nature anti-constructive and we need more construction, not more blame. Accordingly, Americans speculated on blame, fueled by the same media process that spawned tabloid news, but on a separate level, we maintained construction. We all pitched in and tried to make it better as well as we could, including money and time donated through multiple ad hoc relief agencies <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B5">5</abbr></abbrgrp>. And we learned.</p>
			<p>Health care providers, rendered powerless by lack of facilitative technology and hardware, opened their imaginations and thought outside the box to make things work. If sick patients couldn't be extricated in traditional ways, more non-traditional routes mobilized them. Field expediency moved mountains previously thought immobile. Concepts that didn't work were quickly abandoned and other more effective modes were identified by rapid trial and error. When public officials failed, private citizens rallied <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B6">6</abbr></abbrgrp>.</p>
			<p>We learned that trauma isn't the major issue after the event. And so the traditional horde of do-gooders flooding into the area to help actually hindered, as it did after the 9/11 disaster in New York City <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B7">7</abbr></abbrgrp>. It was not previously clear that there is no practical way to evacuate a major city, and any attempt to do so also limits mobility within the disaster area as well <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B8">8</abbr></abbrgrp>. All roads and airports are jammed. There is no way to get anywhere after any government air transport is facilitated. Ultimately, escaping citizens were told they might be safer staying in their homes than trying to flee <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B9">9</abbr></abbrgrp>. Others refused to leave the perceived safety of tried and true, placing themselves and rescuers in jeopardy. Accordingly, a major problem will be dealing with transportation of and living arrangements for thousands of victims, not treating their illnesses. Additionally, the issue of integrating thousands and potentially millions of people into new social and physical environments must be dealt with.</p>
			<p>We are learning about the nature of "martial law", rarely used in the past, and how it applies to the future. Use of Federal troops for domestic support is problematic because of its potential abuse of civil liberties and it's legality problems. But, if anything, the Katrina disaster has shown it will be necessary for some centralized authority to take control of disaster management much earlier than we previously thought. Society has to give up some of its individual liberties to promote order and avoid anarchy during National emergencies. The military has the organizational ability to do many things that civilians can't, no matter how well intentioned. But it must be remembered that military stabilization is a very cold, dispassionate business, performed by humorless, authoritative proponents carrying weapons <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B10">10</abbr></abbrgrp>. Are we willing to pay that price for order <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B11">11</abbr></abbrgrp>?</p>
			<p>We are learning that communications ability must be a reality long before any disaster occurs, not trying to figure it out after the event. It seems clear that the event caused major network outages which could have been preventable with more planning <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B12">12</abbr></abbrgrp>. Satellite backbones do not yet have the carrying capacity to provide core infrastructure but this will come in time. Also, wireless LAN and WAN will become important for local communication. Relatively antiquated communication modes such as Amateur Radio have enjoyed resurgence, and coupled with satellite Internet capability may well revolutionize our effective response to disaster care <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B13">13</abbr></abbrgrp>.</p>
			<p>Perhaps most of all, we are slowly learning that entitled individuals living in very comfortable circumstances have a real potential to find themselves in dire straits even if they see disaster coming and have time to plan. Power can go out for huge areas for days or weeks. Potable water flow can cease. Damage can be done from almost any front. It is now clear that private citizens must move to establish a drill to protect themselves and their families now <abbrgrp><abbr bid="B14">14</abbr></abbrgrp>. At the very least, a supply of drinking water must be secured. A small power generator to provide electricity for essentials. A supply of stabilized gasoline (lasts for years) to run the generator and power automobiles for essential and emergency travel.</p>
			<p>This is the future of disaster management.</p>
		</sec>
	</bdy>
	<bm>
		<refgrp>
			<bibl id="B1">
				<title>
					<p>Recommendations for Life-Supporting First-Aid training of the lay public for disaster preparedness</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Angus</snm>
						<fnm>DC</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Pretto</snm>
						<fnm>EA</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Abrams</snm>
						<fnm>JI</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Safar</snm>
						<fnm>P</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<source>Prehospital Disaster Med</source>
				<volume>8</volume>
				<issue>2</issue>
				<fpage>157</fpage>
				<lpage>60</lpage>
				<note>1993 Apr-Jun</note>
				<xrefbib>
					<pubid idtype="pmpid">10155460</pubid>
				</xrefbib>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B2">
				<title>
					<p>Similarities to the 1988 earthquake in Armenia: time to teach the public life-supporting first aid?</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Crippen</snm>
						<fnm>D</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<cnm>The World Trade Center attack</cnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<source>Crit Care</source>
				<pubdate>2001</pubdate>
				<volume>5</volume>
				<issue>6</issue>
				<fpage>312</fpage>
				<lpage>4</lpage>
				<note>Epub 2001 Nov 6</note>
				<xrefbib>
					<pubidlist>
						<pubid idtype="pmcid">137377</pubid>
						<pubid idtype="pmpid" link="fulltext">11737915</pubid>
						<pubid idtype="doi">10.1186/cc1058</pubid>
					</pubidlist>
				</xrefbib>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B3">
				<title>
					<p>The Kimery report: Katrina Exposes Post-9/11 Disaster Unpreparedness</p>
				</title>
				<url>http://www.hstoday.us/Kimery_Report/20050911_Katrina_Lays_Bare_Post_911_Catastrophe_Unpreparedness.cfm</url>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B4">
				<title>
					<p>Going ... going ... gone? Federal Emergency Management Agency</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Gresham</snm>
						<fnm>R</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<source>Emerg Med Serv</source>
				<pubdate>1994</pubdate>
				<volume>23</volume>
				<issue>1</issue>
				<fpage>42</fpage>
				<lpage>52</lpage>
				<xrefbib>
					<pubid idtype="pmpid">10131244</pubid>
				</xrefbib>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B5">
				<url>http://www1.salvationarmy.org/</url>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B6">
				<title>
					<p>The Gulf Coast's Devastation: Nurses respond to Hurricane Katrina</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Kennedy</snm>
						<fnm>MS</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Jacobson</snm>
						<fnm>J</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<source>Am J Nurs</source>
				<pubdate>2005</pubdate>
				<volume>105</volume>
				<issue>10</issue>
				<fpage>19</fpage>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B7">
				<title>
					<p>The World Trade Center attack. Doctors in the fire and police services</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Martinez</snm>
						<fnm>C</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Gonzalez</snm>
						<fnm>D</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<source>Crit Care</source>
				<pubdate>2001</pubdate>
				<volume>5</volume>
				<issue>6</issue>
				<fpage>304</fpage>
				<lpage>6</lpage>
				<note>Epub 2001 Nov 6</note>
				<xrefbib>
					<pubidlist>
						<pubid idtype="pmcid">137374</pubid>
						<pubid idtype="pmpid" link="fulltext">11737912</pubid>
						<pubid idtype="doi">10.1186/cc1055</pubid>
					</pubidlist>
				</xrefbib>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B8">
				<title>
					<p>Thousands Fleeing Rita Jam Roads From Coast</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Harden</snm>
						<fnm>B</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Moren</snm>
						<fnm>S</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<publisher>Washington Post Staff Writers</publisher>
				<note>Friday, September 23, 2005</note>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B9">
				<title>
					<p>Rita: Running Out of Gas in Evacuation Traffic Jams</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Joyner</snm>
						<fnm>J</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<url>http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/archives/12080</url>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B10">
				<title>
					<p>Rescuers to stay armed</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Villa</snm>
						<fnm>J</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<source>The Arizona Republic</source>
				<note>Oct. 7, 2005 12:00 AM</note>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B11">
				<title>
					<p>New Orleans becomes a war zone. A dress rehearsal for martial law?</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Van Auken</snm>
						<fnm>B</fnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<url>http://www.wsws.org/articles/2005/sep2005/nola-s08.shtml</url>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B12">
				<title>
					<p>Hurricane Katrina response and guidance for health-care providers, relief workers, and shelter operators</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<cnm>Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)</cnm>
					</au>
				</aug>
				<source>MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep</source>
				<volume>54</volume>
				<issue>35</issue>
				<fpage>877</fpage>
				<note>2005 Sep 9</note>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B13">
				<title>
					<p>The amateur Radio Emergency Service (ARES) and the National Disaster Medical System (NDMS)</p>
				</title>
				<aug>
					<au>
						<snm>Niemtzow</snm>
						<fnm>RC</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Yarbrough</snm>
						<fnm>G</fnm>
					</au>
					<au>
						<snm>Harwood</snm>
						<fnm>KL</fnm>
					</au>
					<etal/>
				</aug>
				<source>Mil Med</source>
				<pubdate>1993</pubdate>
				<volume>158</volume>
				<issue>4</issue>
				<fpage>259</fpage>
				<lpage>63</lpage>
				<xrefbib>
					<pubid idtype="pmpid">8479634</pubid>
				</xrefbib>
			</bibl>
			<bibl id="B14">
				<url>http://www.fema.gov/</url>
			</bibl>
		</refgrp>
	</bm>
</art>
