Mild induced hypothermia after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: persisting doubts about patient safety

cc6084 CCJ Letter Mild induced hypothermia after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: persisting doubts about patient safety Patel M Bhavesh Patel.bhavesh@mayo.edu Chapital B Alyssa chapital.alyssa@mayo.edu Rady Y Mohamed rady.mohamed@mayo.edu Larson S Joel Larson.joel@mayo.edu

Department of Critical Care Medicine, Mayo Clinic Hospital, Mayo Clinic Arizona, 5777 East Mayo Boulevard, Phoenix, AZ 85054, USA

Critical Care 1364-8535 2007 11 4 420 http://ccforum.com/content/11/4/420 See related research by Pichon et al., http://ccforum.com/content/11/3/R71 1776459310.1186/cc6084 27 8 2007 2007 BioMed Central Ltd

In a study of the endovascular cooling system Alsius CoolGard™ combined with the Icy™ venous catheter, Pichon and colleagues concluded the effectiveness and safety of mild induced hypothermia (MIH) after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest resuscitation 1. We are troubled because the study has reproduced several safety concerns about MIH that have not been confronted.

First, the sixfold increase of the nosocomial bloodstream infection rate (13% versus control 2%) is most probably related to insertion of endovascular catheters for MIH 1. Bloodstream infection in patients with endovascular catheters can become a significant cause of preventable morbidity and mortality 2.

Second, it is unclear why hypokalemia (75% of MIH cases) was dismissed as a factor for the incidence of cardiac dysrhythmia 1. Temperature changes induce electrolyte shifts and thus influence the depolarization and repolarization times and the conduction velocity of action potentials within the myocardium, promoting aberrant conduction pathways. Electrolyte abnormalities associated with MIH can influence electrophysiological parameters of the myocardium, triggering dysrhythmia 3.

Third, it can be argued that MIH may have contributed to refractory cardiogenic shock and early death. MIH blunts the myocardial response to inotropic medications and increases the requirement for vasopressors to maintain hemodynamic stability 4. The survival benefit for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest from an early intervention for coronary reperfusion and restoration of optimal cardiac performance substantially exceeds the survival benefit from MIH 5.

Fourth, MIH can prolong and augment the activation of inflammatory cytokines 6; manifesting with rebound hyperthermia upon re-warming (74% of MIH cases) 1. The cytokine response to MIH can diminish the favorable neuro-protective effect, and can perhaps exacerbate acute organ injury.

Fifth, the concurrent use of muscle relaxants in MIH may conceal clinical signs of epileptic activity after cardiopulmonary resuscitation and hypoxic insult to the brain. Continuous monitoring of the electroencephalogram is necessary to detect and treat provoked epileptic activity, otherwise secondary neuronal injury can progress during MIH 7. Immediate neurophysiologic studies after cardiopulmonary resuscitation suggest that MIH has a limited therapeutic benefit for neurologic salvage or protection 8.

It is imperative to recognize that MIH as a treatment modality after cardiopulmonary resuscitation has a narrow safety margin, and its misapplication can lead to unintended deleterious consequences 9. Pichon and colleagues highlight several safety concerns that must be addressed before recommending the broad application of endovascular cooling devices in clinical practice.

Authors' response

Nicolas Pichon and Bruno François

We assent to the potential relationship between the development of nosocomial bloodstream infection and MIH, and future specific studies may provide clarity about this relationship. Moreover, we agree that hypothermia probably induces electrolyte shifts, but the literature demonstrates that the influence of electrolyte disorders on potential dysrythmia and the risk of arrhythmias increase significantly when the temperature drops below 30°C, which is not the case in our study 1011. Concerning the cardiogenic shocks, MIH may have contributed to worsening hemodynamics and therefore should not be induced in these patients until further data are available. Two studies, however, have demonstrated that MIH seems beneficial in these conditions 412. The endovascular cooling system does not exclude an early intervention for coronary reperfusion, and the association of MIH and coronary reperfusion may increase the survival rate 12.

The 'rebound hyperthermia' frequently observed after rewarming may decrease the beneficial effects of MIH on brain injury and has not yet been clearly explained 10. An additional use of the cooling system (target temperature of 37°C for several hours) after rewarming appears an efficient technique to avoid 'rebound hyperthermia' and the activation of inflammatory cytokines, but deserves further study (unpublished data).

Hypothermia alone significantly reduces the number of and the severity of motor seizures, and exhibits anticonvulsant effects in addition to the large use of benzodiazepines for sedation 13.

Even if several safety concerns remain to be investigated, none of the adverse effects result in a worsened outcome. In addition, the beneficial effect of the endovascular cooling system by far exceeds the complications.

Abbreviations

MIH = mild induced hypothermia.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Efficacy and tolerance of mild induced hypothermia after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest using an endovascular cooling system Pichon N Amiel JB François B Dugard A Etchecopar C Vignon P Crit Care 2007 11 R71 10.1186/cc5956 17598898 An intervention to decrease catheter-related bloodstream infections in the ICU Pronovost P Needham D Berenholtz S Sinopoli D Chu H Cosgrove S Sexton B Hyzy R Welsh R Roth G N Engl J Med 2006 355 2725 2732 10.1056/NEJMoa061115 17192537 Effects of hypothermia, potassium, and verapamil on the action potential characteristics of canine cardiac purkinje fibers Sprung JMDP Laszlo AMD Turner LAMD Kampine JPMDP Bosnjak ZJP Anesthesiology 1995 82 713 722 10.1097/00000542-199506000-00023 7879939 From evidence to clinical practice: effective implementation of therapeutic hypothermia to improve patient outcome after cardiac arrest Oddo M Schaller MD Feihl F Ribordy V Liaudet L Crit Care Med 2006 34 1865 1873 16715035 Treatment and outcome in post-resuscitation care after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest when a modern therapeutic approach was introduced Werling M Thoren AB Axelsson C Herlitz J Resuscitation 2007 73 40 45 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2006.08.018 17241730 Hypothermia prolongs activation of NF-kappaB and augments generation of inflammatory cytokines Fairchild KD Singh IS Patel S Drysdale BE Viscardi RM Hester L Lazusky HM Hasday JD Am J Physiol Cell Physiol 2004 287 C422 C431 10.1152/ajpcell.00507.2003 15070815 EEG should be performed during induced hypothermia Hovland A Nielsen EW Kluver J Salvesen R Resuscitation 2006 68 143 146 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2005.05.019 16325321 Reduced effectiveness of hypothermia in patients lacking the wave V in auditory brainstem responses immediately following resuscitation from cardiac arrest Sakurai A Kinoshita K Moriya T Utagawa A Ebihara T Furukawa M Tanjoh K Resuscitation 2006 70 52 58 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2005.10.026 16784997 Therapeutic hypothermia after cardiac arrest: unintentional overcooling is common using ice packs and conventional cooling blankets Merchant RM Abella BS Peberdy MA Soar J Ong ME Schmidt GA Becker LB Vanden Hoek TL Crit Care Med 2006 34 12 Suppl S490 S494 10.1097/01.CCM.0000246016.28679.36 17114983 Application of therapeutic hypothermia in the intensive care unit: opportunities and pitfalls of a promising treatment modality. Part II: practical aspects and side effects Polderman KH Intensive Care Med 2004 30 757 769 10.1007/s00134-003-2151-y 14767590 Mild therapeutic hypothermia to improve the neurologic outcome after cardiac arrest Hypothermia after Cardiac Arrest Study Group N Engl J Med 2002 346 549 556 10.1056/NEJMoa012689 11856793 Therapeutic hypothermia after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: experiences with patients treated with percutaneous coronary intervention and cardiogenic shock Hovdenes J Laake JH Aaberge L Haugaa H Bugge JF Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2007 51 137 142 10.1111/j.1399-6576.2006.01209.x 17181536 Anticonvulsivant properties of hypothermia in experimental status epilepticus Schmitt FC Buchheim K Meierkord H Holtkamp M Neurobiol Dis 2006 23 689 696 10.1016/j.nbd.2006.05.008 16843675