Introduction
Sepsis is a significant cause of morbidity and mortality in neonates and adults, and the mortality rate from sepsis doubles in patients who develop cardiovascular dysfunction and septic shock 1. Annual combined deaths from sepsis of patients of all ages equal the number of deaths from myocardial infarction 2, and 7% of all childhood deaths result from sepsis alone 3. Sepsis is especially devastating in the neonatal population, as it is responsible for 45% of late deaths in the neonatal intensive care unit, making it one of the leading causes of death for hospitalized infants 4.
The incidence of sepsis is age-related, and is highest in infants (5.3/1,000) and the elderly over 65 years of age (26.2/1,000) 2. Although the incidence is highest in the elderly, both the intensive care unit admission rates (58.5% versus 40%) and the average costs ($54,300 versus $14,600) are higher in infants 2. Twenty-one percent of very low birthweight infants will develop at least one episode of culture-proven bloodstream sepsis after the first 3 days of life 5, and the septic episode will probably be more severe than in adults 3. In very low birthweight infants, sepsis increases the hospital stay by 30% and increases mortality 2.5 times 5.
Unlike adults, little is known about the cardiovascular response to sepsis in the neonate. Baseline neonatal cardiovascular function has not been well defined, and studies of inotrope use to treat hypotension in neonates have failed to show any improvement in short-term or long-term clinical outcomes 6. In addition, recent research has demonstrated that the clinical presentation, mechanisms, inflammatory response, response to treatment and outcome of neonatal sepsis vary not only from that of adults, but vary among neonates based on gestational age. The goal of the present article is to review key pathophysiologic aspects of sepsis-related cardiovascular dysfunction, with an emphasis on defining known differences between adult and neonatal populations. The potential impact of these differences on therapeutic strategies is also discussed.
Innate immunity/inflammatory response
Underlying the differences in neonatal and adult sepsis are alterations in the developing immune system. These differences include innate and acquired immunity, immune cell numbers and function, cytokine elaboration and the inflammatory response.
The influence of perinatal factors on the development and response to sepsis is unique to newborns. Challenges to the maternal immune system before and during pregnancy have been associated with modulation of the neonatal immune response, and this modulation occurs in both humoral and cell-mediated immunity 7. Although proinflammatory cytokines such as TNFα, IL-1β and IL-6 have not been shown to cross the human term placenta 8, certain immunoglobulins and lymphoid cells can cross the placenta and change fetal and postnatal immune development 7. The transplacental transfer of immunoglobulins, however, does not occur until 32 weeks gestation 9, leading to a relative immune deficiency in extremely premature infants. Labor of any duration may be immunologically beneficial to the neonate, with improved neutrophil survival and lipopolysaccharide (LPS) responsiveness 10. Labor itself is a mild pro-inflammatory state and has been associated with delayed neutrophil apoptosis, fetal leukocytosis and elevation of the systemic neutrophil count when compared with cesarean section without labor 10. In addition, respiratory burst, CD11b/CD18 and IL-8 receptors have all been shown to be increased after vaginal delivery in comparison with cesarean section 11.
Cytokines
Severe infection can induce the systemic inflammatory response syndrome and can lead to the development of septic shock, which is associated with elevated levels of proinflammatory cytokines including IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8 and TNFα 12. LPS is a cell wall component of Gram-negative bacteria, and is the main endotoxin implicated in the initiation of the proinflammatory response 13. If this extreme inflammatory response is not counterbalanced by a competent compensatory anti-inflammatory response syndrome, the resultant exaggerated inflammatory response leads to increased morbidity and mortality during sepsis 14. The concentration of proinflammatory cytokines is higher in patients with septic shock than in those with severe sepsis, and elevated levels of IL-1β, IL-6 and IL-8 are associated with an increase in early mortality (<48 hours) 12. Sepsis also has the potential to develop into a bimodal disease initially characterized by a proinflammatory state and progressing to a state of immune suppression and immunoparalysis 1516, which is related to increased production of IL-10 17 and decreased HLA-DR expression 18. The resultant immune suppression appears to be confined to the blood compartment, however, while a hyperinflammatory state persists in tissues, which makes defining the role of cytokines in sepsis more difficult 19.
The inflammatory cytokine response to sepsis differs in neonates and adults. Although premature infants were once believed to have deficient production of proinflammatory cytokines, intrauterine fetal cord blood samples taken between 21 and 32 weeks gestation have demonstrated significant synthesis of IL-6, IL-8 and TNFα 20. Term and preterm infants have been shown to have a higher percentage of IL-6-positive and IL-8-positive cells than adults, with preterm infants having the highest percentage of IL-8-positive cells 21. After stimulation with LPS, this increased percentage of proinflammatory cells in neonates is more pronounced and occurs faster than in adults. In addition, the compensatory anti-inflammatory response system in neonates appears to be immature, with both term and preterm infants demonstrating profoundly decreased IL-10 production and a lower amount of transforming growth factor beta-positive lymphocytes than do adults after LPS stimulation 14. Although there is a decrease in the absolute amount of IL-10 produced, an increase in the IL-10:TNFα ratio has been reported in premature infants after LPS exposure; an increased IL-10:TNFα ratio in critically ill adults has been shown to be a negative predictor of outcome 22. These perinatal and developmental influences on innate immunity and the inflammatory response may significantly alter the neonate's response to pathogen exposure.
Neutrophils
In addition to cytokine differences in the neonate, eosinophils, macrophages and polymorphonuclear neutrophils have reduced surface binding components and have defective opsonization, phagocytosis and antigen-processing capabilities, leading to a generally less robust response to pathogen exposure. Polymorphonuclear neutrophil function is the primary line of defense in the cellular immune system, and there is an alteration in both neutrophil function and survival in neonates versus adults. Neonates, especially those born prematurely, display a pattern of infectious diseases similar to the pattern seen in older individuals with severe neutropenia 20, have a markedly decreased neutrophil storage pool and cell mass 2324, and are more likely to develop neutropenia during systemic infection 25. Functional deficiencies of neutrophils in preterm and stressed/septic neonates include chemotaxis 26, endothelial adherence 20, migration 27, phagocytosis and bactericidal potency 202829. The NADPH oxidase system, however, may be a first-line mechanism of innate immunity as there is a direct negative correlation between oxidative burst product generation and gestational age 20. This could, however, have a detrimental effect on preterm infants as exaggerated oxygen free radical formation may contribute to the development of such neonatal diseases as retinopathy of prematurity and broncho-pulmonary dysplasia, as well as to cardiovascular disease.
Cardiovascular dysfunction in sepsis
Sepsis is clinically characterized by systemic inflammation, cardiovascular dysfunction, an inability of oxygen delivery to meet oxygen demand, an altered substrate metabolism and, ultimately, multiorgan failure and death 30. The mortality rate from sepsis doubles in patients who develop cardiovascular dysfunction and septic shock 1. Little is known about the cardiovascular effects of sepsis in the neonate, but the developing cardiomyocyte differs from that of the adult and may lead to differences in the cardiac response to sepsis and inflammation. In addition to underlying differences in the structure of the neonatal cardiomyocyte, functional alterations in proliferative activity 31 and excitation–contraction coupling 32 have been identified. These differences may be mediated by alterations in calcium channel expression and activity 3334, in ATP-sensitive potassium channel function 35 and in β-receptor coupling 36, and may contribute to differences in sepsis outcomes and therapeutic responses in neonates versus adults.
Cardiac dysfunction and cardiovascular collapse during sepsis result from increased levels of TNFα 37 and from increased cardiac myocyte production of nitric oxide and peroxynitrite 38, which leads to further DNA damage and ATP depletion 39, resulting in secondary energy failure 40. In addition, serum from patients with septic shock directly causes a decreased maximum extent and peak velocity of contraction, activates transcription factors for proinflammatory cytokines and induces apoptosis in cultured myocytes 41. LPS-induced production of TNFα has been associated with increased apoptosis and cell death in adult cultured cardiomyocytes 42, and this ventricular myocyte apoptosis has been linked to cardiovascular dysfunction in adult whole animal experiments 43. Neonatal cardiomyocytes, however, do not exhibit an increase in apoptosis despite an increase in TNFα production after LPS exposure, suggesting another mechanism for sepsis-associated cardiovascular dysfunction in neonates 44.
Septic shock is characterized in adults by a hyperdynamic phase with decreased left ventricular ejection fraction, decreased systemic vascular resistance and an increased cardiac index 4546. Underlying coronary artery disease, cardiomyopathy and congestive heart failure may contribute to the systolic and diastolic ventricular dysfunction described in the setting of adult sepsis. The resultant myocardial depression does not appear to be related to ischemia, however, as the coronary blood flow and coronary sinus lactate levels have been found to be normal in patients with septic shock 4748.
Myocardial dysfunction in childhood septic shock reaches its maximum within hours and is the main cause of mortality 3049. In comparison with adults, children more often present in a nonhyperdynamic state with decreased cardiac output and increased systemic vascular resistance 4650 and can develop this nonhyperdynamic septic shock even after fluid resuscitation 51. This low cardiac output is associated with an increase in mortality 5253. Owing to a limited number of research studies in the very young, the hemodynamic response of premature infants and neonates is not well understood, and the presenting hemodynamic abnormalities are more variable than in older children and adults 50. Complicating the clinical evaluation of these patients is the observation that blood pressure is a poor indicator of systemic blood flow in neonates 654.
In both premature and full-term infants, left ventricular systolic performance is highly dependent on afterload, which may increase the susceptibility of neonates to sudden cardiac deterioration in the setting of shock and vasoconstriction 5556. Newborn infants also have a relatively decreased left ventricular muscle mass 57 and an increased ratio of type I collagen (determinant of tissue rigidity) to type III collagen (provides elasticity) in myocardial tissue 58, which may account for the impaired left ventricular diastolic function and the alterations in mid-wall left ventricular fractional shortening seen in premature infants 59. These physiologic abnormalities, coupled with the finding that the neonatal left ventricular myocardium already functions at a higher baseline contractile state 55, may limit the neonate's ability to increase the stroke volume or myocardial contractility in the setting of sepsis. Complicating the cardiovascular response to sepsis in the neonate are additional morbidities, including reopening of a patent ductus arteriosus and the development of persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn due to cytokine elaboration, acidosis and hypoxia in the setting of sepsis 52. These underlying differences in anatomy, physiology and adaptive cardiovascular function exemplify the need to more specifically identify and understand the cardiovascular response to sepsis in the neonate in order to develop successful therapeutic strategies.
Treatment
The short-term goal of treatment is to optimize the perfusion and delivery of oxygen and nutrients, to correct and/or prevent metabolic derangements resulting from cellular hypo-perfusion and to support organ and body functions until homeostasis is achieved 3060. Although our understanding of the pathophysiologic mechanisms of sepsis and septic shock has improved over the past 10 years, the mortality and morbidity associated with sepsis continues to be high 23046. Proinflammatory cytokines have been implicated in the pathogenesis of organ dysfunction during sepsis, but the modulation of single gene products (TNFα, IL-1β, inducible nitric oxide synthase) and nonpeptide mediators (platelet-activating factor, prostaglandin or leukotriene inhibitors) has not been shown to improve mortality in sepsis and septic shock 41.
Unlike adult and pediatric critical medicine, where there are extensively studied multiple organ dysfunction scores and well-defined algorhythmic guidelines for treatment 61, there is a large amount of practice variability in neonatal sepsis. The American College of Critical Care Medicine concluded that the adult guidelines for hemodynamic support of septic shock are not applicable to children and neonates, and published guidelines for these younger age groups 52. Premature neonates, however, were not specifically addressed.
Antibiotics
Empiric therapy aimed at the most probable causative pathogens should be started immediately upon suspicion of clinical sepsis, as a delay in the initiation of antibiotics has been associated with an increased risk of mortality in both pediatric 3062 and adult 136364 patients with sepsis. In neonates, special developmental characteristics such as immaturity of the hepatic and renal clearance systems need to be considered when prescribing an antibiotic regimen.
Fluid resuscitation
Fluid resuscitation is an important mainstay in the resuscitation of patients with septic shock, as marked hypovolemia may result from vasodilation and increased capillary leak. A significant reduction in mortality has been demonstrated when hemodynamic function is optimized within the first few hours after presentation of sepsis 60. There has been longstanding debate about the use of colloids or crystalloids, but there is currently no strong evidence supporting the superiority of either fluid agent in the resuscitation of septic shock 1365666768. The underlying importance is the maintenance of preload and tissue perfusion. Fluid resuscitation is necessary in premature infants, but must be provided with caution due to the risks of developing intraventricular hemorrhage from fluctuations in cerebral perfusion and developing heart failure and/or pulmonary overcirculation from resultant left to right flow through a patent ductus arteriosus 52.
Cardiovascular agents
Adult sepsis is most often characterized by a hyperdynamic state with vasodilation, while neonatal sepsis may be a hypodynamic state with vasoconstriction and may respond better to inotrope and vasodilator therapy 30. In both the recent recommendations of the American College of Critical Care 69 and an extensive evidence-based review of vasopressor support in septic shock 70, dopamine and norepinephrine are considered first-line agents in adult septic shock. An attenuated response to adrenergic stimulation has been reported in patients with septic shock, which is thought to result from the downregulation of receptors, uncoupling of receptors from adenylate cyclase or decreased production of cAMP 46. This impaired effectiveness of exogenous adrenergic stimulation may be augmented in neonates due to a functionally immature autonomic nervous system 3071 and elevated baseline levels of catecholamines 72737475, especially in premature infants.
Randomized controlled trials of vasopressors in neonates are extremely rare. In a recent study investigating dopamine versus epinephrine for cardiovascular support in low birth-weight infants, both agents were found to be efficacious in improving the mean arterial blood pressure – but epinephrine was associated with more short-term adverse effects such as enhanced chronotropic response, hyperglycemia requiring insulin treatment and increased plasma lactate levels 76. There is only a weak correlation between blood pressure and systemic blood flow in neonates 6, and, although a recent metanalysis found dopamine to be superior to dobutamine in improving blood pressure, a randomized controlled trial showed that dobutamine increased systemic blood flow more effectively than dopamine 77. According to recently published clinical practice parameters, however, dopamine remains the first-line agent in neonates, and epinephrine may be used in dopamine-resistant septic shock 52. If low cardiac output and high systemic vascular resistance persist, dobutamine and/or a type III phosphodiesterase inhibitor may be indicated 4652. Phosphodiesterase inhibitors have the additional benefits of TNFα attenuation and decreased myocardial inducible nitric oxide synthase activity 46, and milrinone has been shown to improve cardiovascular function in pediatric patients with septic shock 78.
Milrinone is a selective phosphodiesterase type III inhibitor that has proven safe and efficacious in certain clinical scenarios in pediatric patients 7879. Many of these studies, however, have been conducted by providing a loading dose of milrinone followed by a continuous infusion. In practice, physicians often forego the loading dose, especially in patients that may have decreased preload to avoid any untoward hemodynamic effects including undue hypotension. The time to reach steady state is therefore prolonged compared with the pharmacokinetics previously described 80. Despite this approach, many patients are concomitantly on catecholamine infusions, which have a very short half-life. The glomerular filtration rate in term neonates is 20 ml/min × 1.73 m2, which is generally twice that of premature newborns 81. The glomerular filtration rate improves over the first several weeks of life in all newborns but the velocity at which it improves is less in premature infants. In term newborns, the glomerular filtration rate doubles in the first 2 weeks of life 8283. These differences in glomerular filtration rate values among varying gestational age newborns impact the administration of medications that are primarily eliminated in the renal system. This impact is pertinent in milrinone use, and therefore dosing is often renally adjusted in neonates. In cases of persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn associated with sepsis, inhaled nitric oxide may help reduce pulmonary vascular resistance and off-load the right ventricle.
Immunomodulating agents
Agents such as corticosteroids, pentoxifylline and recombinant human-activated protein C have been studied as adjunctive treatments for sepsis in adults and neonates (Table 1). Recombinant human-activated protein C is the only adjunctive therapy approved for the treatment of severe sepsis in adults who have a high risk of death 8485.
<p>Table 1</p>
Immunomodulating agents in neonatal and adult sepsis
Agent
Neonates
Adults
Steroids
No evidence of improved outcome in critically ill infants or children with sepsis [89]
High-dose: no benefit [101] or reduction in mortality [102], may actually increase mortality [86]
Hemodynamically stable: no benefit [101]
Low-dose, long-course: may decrease mortality [87]
Intravenous immunoglobulin
Prevention: 3% reduction in sepsis, 4% reduction in any serious infection; no change in mortality, necrotizing enterocolitis, bronchopulmonary dysplasia, intraventricular hemorrhage or length of stay [103]
Polyclonal: significant reduction in mortality [105]
Suspected infection: decrease in mortality of borderline statistical significance [104]
Monoclonal: HA-1A, E5, IL-1, phospholipase A2, adhesion molecules and contact factors all show no benefit [86]
Proven infection: no change in mortality [104]
Colony-stimulating factors
Treatment: rhG-CSF and rhGM-CSF not effective in reducing mortality [106,107]
rhG-CSF in pneumonia with severe sepsis: no difference in mortality, ARDS or adverse events [108,109]; no difference in days of ventilatory support or intensive care unit stay [108]
Prophylaxis: both agents effective in correcting neutropenia in premature neonates [106 107]; rhGM-CSF may decrease infection in infants <32 weeks who are neutropenic or at risk for developing neutropenia [106,107]; rhGM-CSF decreases mortality in neutropenic neonates with sepsis [107]
rhG-CSF in severe sepsis: small study shows a significant decrease in mortality [110]
rhG-CSF febrile neutropenia: shorter hospital stay, no difference in mortality [111]
rhGM-CSF in severe sepsis: no change in mortality [112,113]; improved PaO2/FiO2 ratio [112] and clearance of infection [113]
Activated protein C
No randomized trials in neonates [114,115]
Severe sepsis and increased risk of death: improved organ function and decreased mortality [114]; 19.4% reduction in relative risk of death [84]; cost-effective [117]
Two case reports with survival without adverse events [114,116]
Severe sepsis and low risk of death: no benefit [118]
Large pediatric clinical trial stopped early due to no improvement in mortality and increased intracranial hemorrhage [98]
Pentoxifylline
Decreased mortality, circulatory compromise, disseminated intravascular coagulopathy and necrotizing enterocolitis versus placebo [94]
Improved cardiopulmonary function [96] and hemodynamic performance [95]
Reduces mortality without adverse effects [119]
No change in 28-day mortality [95]
No adverse effects [95,96]
ARDS, acute respiratory distress syndrome; rhG-CSF, recombinant human granulocyte colony-stimulating factor; rhGM-CSF, recombinant human granulocyte–macrophage colony-stimulating factor.
Corticosteroids
The use of corticosteroids in the management of sepsis has evolved with the identification of relative adrenal insufficiency, which occurs in 50–75% of patients with septic shock 13. While adult studies of high-dose corticosteroids have not shown a benefit or reduction in mortality 86, lower doses of steroids given over a longer course may actually decrease mortality in adult patients with sepsis 87. The use of corticosteroids in the treatment of sepsis in neonates and children remains relatively untested. A recent study has shown that 44% of children with septic shock are adrenally insufficient 88, but a large cohort study of steroid administration to children and infants with severe sepsis showed no improvement in outcome and an increase in mortality in a subset of patients 89. In neonates, both hydrocortisone and low-dose dexamethasone have been shown to effectively increase blood pressure in refractory hypotension 9091, but steroids should be used with caution as early administration of high-dose corticosteroids has the additional risk of impaired neurodevelopment and clinically significant disability later in life 92.
Pentoxifylline
Pentoxifylline is a methylxanthine derivative and nonspecific phosphodiesterase inhibitor that has been shown to be beneficial in the treatment of a variety of illnesses in all age groups, but only a handful of studies have focused on the use of pentoxifylline in the treatment of sepsis in adults and neonates 93. In premature neonates with sepsis, pentoxifylline has been shown to decrease IL-6 and TNFα levels, to decrease the clinical symptoms of necrotizing enterocolitis, to reduce the development of cardiac, renal or hepatic failure, to decrease the incidence of disseminated intravascular coagulopathy and to improve blood pressure and survival rates 94. Adult studies have shown improved cardiopulmonary and hemodynamic function in severe sepsis 9596 but did not show a reduction in 28-day mortality 96. Both neonatal and adult studies showed no adverse effects of the medication.
Recombinant human-activated protein C
At least 80% of children and adults develop an acquired deficiency of protein C during severe sepsis, and this deficiency is associated with adverse outcomes, such as multiple organ failure and mortality 97. In the PROWESS trial, the use of in the treatment of adults with severe sepsis and a high risk of death showed a relative risk reduction of mortality of 19% 84. A large clinical trial in pediatric patients with sepsis was stopped early due to a lack of demonstrated benefit and the finding of an increased risk of intracranial hemorrhage, especially in infants younger than 60 days of life 98. In addition to the potential risk for increased bleeding in the neonatal population, the efficacy of recombinant human-activated protein C may also be different in neonates due to underlying developmental differences in the coagulation pathway. The anticoagulant effect of recombinant human-activated protein C has been shown to be decreased in neonatal cord plasma, which is due, in part, to the lower levels of tissue factor pathway inhibitor, antithrombin and protein S in neonatal versus adult plasma 8485.
Conclusion
The incidence of neonatal sepsis is significant, with suspected sepsis being the most common diagnosis on admission to the neonatal intensive care unit in the United States 99. Research regarding neonatal sepsis, and the cardiovascular effects of sepsis in particular, is relatively lacking. The cost of neonatal sepsis is high, with very low birthweight infants and low birthweight infants with sepsis consuming twice as much financial resource than do infants with respiratory distress syndrome 3. Future medical and social resource utilization is also increased, as there is a significant increase in the morbidity of infants surviving severe infection, with a 30–400% odds increase of later neuro-developmental impairment 100.
In the neonate, there are multiple developmental alterations in both the response to pathogens and the response to treatment that distinguish this age group from adults. Differences in innate immunity and cytokine response may predispose neonates to the harmful effects of proinflammatory cytokines and oxidative stress, leading to severe organ dysfunction and sequelae during infection and inflammation 14. Underlying differences in cardiovascular anatomy, function and response to treatment may further alter the neonate's response to pathogen exposure. We must therefore gain a greater understanding of these developmental changes in order to adequately understand and treat immune and inflammatory-related cardiovascular compromise in the neonatal population. This remarkably unstudied area of neonatal sepsis is paramount, as cardiac failure remains a main cause of death in this disease state. Translational research will be the cornerstone of this research initiative, as therapeutic agents will need to be developmentally targeted in order to be effective.
Abbreviations
IL = interleukin; LPS = lipopolysaccharide; TNF = tissue necrosis factor.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
WAL was primarily responsible for the conception and design of the present review, as well as the intellectual content, drafting and revision of the manuscript. TMH and JAB also contributed significantly to the design of the review, added important intellectual content and participated in the drafting and revision of the manuscript. All three authors gave final approval of the version to be published.